Pinehills Golf Club - Nicklaus

Pinehills Golf Club: A Public Course That Plays Like a Private Club

Pinehills Golf Club isn’t just another public course—it’s one of the best in Massachusetts. Located in Plymouth, this 36-hole golf haven offers two championship-level courses that deliver a premium golf experience without the exclusivity of a private club. Whether you’re teeing it up on the Rees Jones Course or the Nicklaus Design Course, you’re in for a round that challenges your skills while spoiling you with pristine conditions.

If you want a public course that feels high-end, this is it.

A Layout for Every Golfer—But Don’t Expect an Easy Ride

With two distinct courses, Pinehills gives golfers options. One leans tactical, the other lets you let it rip—but neither is a walk in the park.

The Rees Jones Course: Precision is King

This course demands accuracy, with tree-lined fairways, strategically placed bunkers, and fast, undulating greens. If you can’t shape your shots, expect to be chipping out from under a lot of trees.

Hole 8 is a perfect example—197 yard par-3 with a green protected on three sides by water, sand and trees. It's beautiful, but even the most accurate golfers can struggle to find the green on this one.

The Nicklaus Design Course: More Forgiving, but Still a Challenge

The Nicklaus course gives you a little more breathing room. Wider fairways and larger greens make it a bit more accessible for mid-handicappers, but don’t confuse that with easy.

The real challenge comes on the greens—sneaky slopes and deceptive breaks can make a three-putt a real possibility if you don’t read them right. Hole 15 is a fun one—a 189 yard par-3 where the hazards start right after the tee box and don't end until you reach the green. Coming up short just isn't an option.

Course Conditions: Always Top-Notch

If there’s one thing Pinehills is known for, it’s immaculate course conditions.

• Fairways? Like carpet—perfectly maintained and a dream to hit from.
• Greens? Fast, smooth, and demand your full attention.
• Bunkers? Well-groomed, but deep enough to make you regret a misfire.

Public courses don’t always have country club-level conditions, but Pinehills comes close.

Beyond the Course: Premium Facilities

Pinehills isn’t just about great golf—it’s got the kind of extras that make for a full experience.

• Practice Facilities: A massive driving range, short game area, and multiple putting greens—so you can actually warm up properly.
• Clubhouse & Dining: A solid post-round spot with good food, good drinks, and plenty of seating.
• Pro Shop: Fully stocked with everything from premium clubs to emergency sleeves of balls (which you might need).

Overall Experience: Manage Expectations

Pinehills Golf Club is as close as you’ll get to a private club experience on a public course. That said, it’s not the cheapest round in the state, and during peak hours, pace of play can slow down. But if you’re looking for top-tier conditions, challenging layouts, and a round that makes you think, it’s worth every penny.

Final Ratings:

• Course Layout: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5) – Two distinct and well-designed courses that test different aspects of your game.
• ‍Course Conditions: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5) – As close to private club quality as public golf gets.‍
• Amentities: : ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5) – Great facilities, but peak-time congestion can be a factor.‍
• Overall Experience: : ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5) – One of the best public courses in Massachusetts, but expect premium pricing.

‍

Course Difficulty

Pinehills Golf Club isn’t just another public course—it’s a serious test of golf that caters to both mid-handicappers looking for a challenge and seasoned players aiming to fine-tune their game. With two distinct 18-hole layouts, the Rees Jones Course and the Nicklaus Design Course, Pinehills delivers variety, strategy, and just enough bite to keep you on your toes.

Here’s how it stacks up in terms of difficulty:

Slope & Rating: A Legitimate Challenge

• Rees Jones Course: Slope 137, Course Rating 75.4
• Nicklaus Design Course: Slope 141, Course Rating 75.7

These numbers tell the story—Pinehills is not a pushover. The high slope ratings mean even single-digit handicappers will find it a test, while higher-handicap players will need to play smart to avoid big numbers.

For Beginners: Play Smart, or Bring Extra Balls

If you’re new to the game, Pinehills can feel overwhelming—especially from the back tees. However, with multiple tee options, high-handicappers can still enjoy the round by playing conservatively. The Nicklaus Course is the more beginner-friendly of the two, as the wider fairways allow for more breathing room.

For Experienced Golfers: A True Shot-Maker’s Course

Low-handicappers will love Pinehills for its demanding approach shots, well-placed hazards, and greens that require creativity. This is a course that rewards great ball-striking and punishes lazy decision-making. Play aggressively when you can—but expect to be tested on every shot.

Conclusion: A Premium Public Golf Test

Pinehills Golf Club is one of the best public golf challenges in Massachusetts. It’s fair but demanding, rewards strategy over brute force, and offers a true test of shot-making and course management.

Difficulty Rating: 9/10

It’s not impossible, but it will push you to play your best golf. Whether you’re a scratch golfer looking for a test or a mid-handicapper wanting to sharpen your game, Pinehills is a course you’ll want to come back to—just maybe with a few more balls in your bag next time.